Friday, July 5, 2013

Celebrating the Ninth of July

Yesterday was Independence Day in the U.S., but the Fourth of July is not one of my favorite holidays. For various reasons. But partly because the original Declaration of Independence, which was ratified on July 4, 1776, was the declaration of the independence (from British rule) primarily for white males in the Colonies.
While the words “all men are created equal” in the Preamble were later greatly emphasized by the abolitionists, slaves were certainly not considered equal to their white owners in 1776.
And while some might argue that “men” was a generic term, and not gender specific, women in fact were not given the right to vote until 144 years later!
Thus, rather than celebrating July 4, I suggest that it would perhaps be more appropriate for the people of this country to celebrate July 9. Why? Because the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution was ratified on that day in 1868.

Through the years we have all heard much about the First and the Fifth Amendments, and recently especially about the Second Amendment. But for some reason many of us, at least I, have not heard as much about the Fourteenth Amendment.
In fact, it was not until I was in Little Rock in January 2011 and saw words of the Fourteenth Amendment emblazoned on the wall of the Little Rock Central High School National Historic Site Visitor Center that I began to grasp the significance of that constitutional amendment.
On the Fourth of July many USAmericans pledge allegiance to the flag, which, by the way, was not written until 1892 and has been recited in its present version only since 1954. As you all know, that pledge closes with the words “with liberty and justice for all.”
But that was hardly the reality for many people in the U.S. for long, long after July 4, 1776. The Fourteenth Amendment greatly contributed toward making those words ring true.
And it is common to hear “The Star Spangled Banner,” the national anthem, sung on the Fourth of July. Even though we usually hear only the first verse sung, all four verses end with the words “the land of the free and the home of the brave.”
But for decades after July 4, 1776, large numbers of people in the new nation were not free. But the Fourteenth Amendment helped to rectify that situation. Section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment includes these significant words
No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
Those are the words that led to the historic Brown v. Board of Education Supreme Court decision in May 1954 and, consequently, to the integration of Central High School in Little Rock (and other schools) in 1957.
Ninety years earlier, in January 1867, Kansas became the ninth state to ratify the Fourteenth Amendment, and Missouri did so just two weeks later. Then when South Carolina ratified it on July 9, 1868, that meant that 2/3 of the states had done so. The amendment, therefore, became a part of the Constitution.
Yes, we USAmericans have, and will, celebrate the Fourth of July this week, as we should. But even though it is not a national holiday, let’s also celebrate the Ninth of July and commemorate the ratification of the highly significant Fourteenth Amendment.


  1. You're absolutely right, Leroy. Let's start a July-the-ninth movement!

  2. P.S.: Well said, and so concisely, too!

  3. Here are comments from another “Thinking Friend” (who perhaps should not be further identified):

    “Leroy. Your comments were racist. You say the freedom of one race, the black race, is more important than the freedom of all other races. That is racism, pure and simple.”

    1. Well, I don’t think I said anything about freedom for the black race being more important than anyone else’s freedom. But I did imply that perhaps it is hypocritical to celebrate freedom for the white people in the Colonies at a time when the slavery of black people was considered all right by a large segment of those white people, including many of those who signed the Declaration of Independence.

      So, in contrast to the TF’s comments above, perhaps it is racist to celebrate the freedom (“declaration of independence”) of one race, the white race (in the Colonies), when the freedom of other people (all other races?) was not recognized at all (in those Colonies).

  4. On NPR the other day, I heard the opening ceremonies of a GOP gathering. They, of course, recited the Lord's Prayer and the Pledge. Totally unabashed that they, in practice, deny both to anyone not like them - and are putting that attitude into law.

  5. We had a similar debate yesterday on a facebook group to which I belong. Amazingly, except for a very small minority, the great consensus was that we were all (left, right, and center) thankful to be citizens here, rather than where we grew up. We all remember the atrocities along with the good in those lands. Yes, this country has had, and does have issues, but they are relative. Thank you, God.

    I remember threatening words by our local NAACP toward African refugees being settled here. Racism is not a one-way street. Neither are other 'isms. Other "good" groups are just as guilty. Our work as the Church remains cut out for us.

  6. Here is something in a similar vein:

    1. Craig, thanks for sending this link. I enjoyed reading the article, and I found considerable agreement with it.

      My article, though, was intended to be more pro-July Ninth than anti-July Fourth.

      With all good wishes,