Saturday, November 5, 2022

What is and Where is Sacred Space?

Ever since my pastor preached a few weeks ago about sacred space, I have been thinking, off and on, about that topic. Are there certain places that are sacred? Can we come into contact with God (by whatever name God is called) in some places more than others? 

Sacred places/spaces are commonly thought to be religious structures (church buildings, temples, shrines, etc.). Christians are often told that the church building is the “house of God.”

In the Old Testament, Bethel means “house of God.” Jacob dreamed of a ladder leading to heaven, and he named that out-in-the-open space Bethel. It was a sacred space, for he experienced God’s presence there. (See Genesis 28:10~19).

Centuries later under King Solomon, the Temple was built in Jerusalem, and it was deemed the dwelling place of God on earth. Thus, it was considered to be a space more sacred than anywhere else.

In spite of the fact that the first Christians had no church buildings at all, over the past 18 centuries Christians have built increasingly elaborate structures and many, including many church leaders, consider the sanctuary (=sacred space) in those buildings to be where God is met.

When I was a boy, at the beginning of the Sunday morning worship services, the church choir often sang the words of Habakkuk 2:20: “The Lord is in his holy temple . . . let all the earth keep silent before Him.”

Looking back, though, the most sacred spaces/places for me were not in a church building. Sacred spaces for me and many others, such as Jacob, were out in the open not inside a religious structure. For Moses, it was by a burning bush. Indeed, as Elizabeth Barrett Browning sensed,

“Earth's crammed with heaven,
And every common bush afire with God.

That seems to be the way it was for Shug in The Color Purple (which I wrote about recently). She asked Celie if she had ever found God in church. “I never did,” Shug said. “Any God I ever felt in church I brought in with me. And I think all the other folks did too. They come to church to share God, not find God” (Kindle, p. 192).

The sacred spaces where I have sensed God “speaking” most clearly were where I was by myself, mowing hay on the farm where I grew up, driving alone across Missouri or Kentucky, walking down a street in Japan, etc.

That doesn’t mean that attending worship services in church buildings was valueless. Far from it. Still, my most important experiences of God have not been in some sort of “sacred” building or while engaged in some “sacred” activity with other people.

Those most important experiences have been times of prayer and have been when alone with God. For that reason, I believe that any and every place has the potential of being a sacred space. Thus, as I wrote while listening to my pastor’s sermon,

Where there’s prayer, God is there;
The prayer place is sacred space.

Sacred space is abundant when we practice the presence of God. I certainly can’t claim to have achieved what the 17th-century French monk known as Brother Lawrence called “the practice of the presence of God.” (His brief book by that name was published in 1692, a year after his death.)

Brother Lawrence spent much of his life as a lowly monastic kitchen aide. But he “resolved to make the love of God the end of all his actions.” Such was possible by practicing the presence of God in whatever he was doing.

Wherever we sense the presence of God, as Brother Lawrence did in the kitchen, as Shug did in the fields of purple flowers, as I have done in various places, all are sacred spaces.

Meeting God in any sacred space, though, is never just for the purpose of receiving a blessing from God. After Jacob met God at Bethel, God said to him, “Every family of earth will be blessed because of you . . . .”

God blesses us in sacred spaces so we can become a blessing to others, sharing God’s love. 

24 comments:

  1. Here are the first comments received this morning; they are from local Thinking Friend David Nelson:

    "Thanks for the reminder that any space can be sacred space. I share in a ritual on Sunday and other days as practice to not miss the sacred presence when it happens in what might appear to the casual observer as ordinary spaces."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comments, David, and for being the first to share comments today. I probably find less benefit from rituals than you and many of my Christian friends do, but I certainly consider the time spent together at the church worship services to be very beneficial--and being there in person is superior to watching on Zoom.

      Delete
  2. Well said, Leroy! One of the most sacred moments I ever experienced was one night in left field under the lights during a softball game!

    A curious twist on sacred space involves things people think defile sacred spaces. In my first pastorate the man we hired regularly to tune the organ smoked a cigar while doing his work. One of the women in the church thought that was just awful since the organ was right up there by the altar, platform, and lectern. Somehow, the idea that cigar smoking in that sacred space was a defilement would have not occurred to me. In spite of her displeasure, I did not ask him not to smoke when tuning the organ.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comments, Anton--and I would like to hear more about that night under the lights during the softball game.

      Yes, it is interesting how even conservative evangelical churches used to have such a strong sense that the church building, especially the sanctuary, was a "holy temple" that had to be protected from defilement. That is understandable to a degree for the "high churches" with their emphasis on ritual, but seems strange for the "low churches" such as you and I grew up in. But in spite of that, maybe it was because of growing up in the low church tradition, I never have seen much difference between "sacred" and non-sacred spaces. In the comment you posted on Oct. 28 (which I never responded to until now), you wrote that "there is no place where God ain't." So, it is possible to sense God during a softball game (although I'm not sure I ever did, perhaps because I was too competitive) as listening to the organ in a church service.

      Delete
    2. I will have to pay more attention the next time I am out in left field because I have not had the experience. That is six months away so I may fail again.

      My favorite times were at the end of Boy Scout campouts and at Scout camp when we disbursed to private spots to reflect. I did have moments in the 2BC chapel with Joy Steincross leading the music. There are other times when music moves me even though I do not sing loudly.

      Delete
    3. Thanks for your comments, Dennis. I never was a Boy Scout, but I was impressed that at Scout camp you had the opportunity to be in a private spot to reflect. As a boy I went to a church camp for 3-4 days ever summer and enjoyed those times greatly, but I don't remember ever having private time structured into the program. Looking back, I think that would have been a good addition to the activities there.

      Delete
  3. Shug in The Color Purple is correct. Sadly, it's all too common that one might leave a worship service "within walls" not having been guided or prompted to acknowledge the presence and power of God's Spirit "closer than our own breath," probing and piercing to the root of our souls, emerging from within us, as Jesus promised, like a gushing fountain. Leroy, your final statement declares the gospel truth that we are God's instruments of extending that radically inclusive sacred space, that font, to others.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Jerry, for your important (and gratifying) comments. I hope most of my Thinking Friends will be able to grasp what you expressed here.

      Delete
  4. Here are comments from Thinking Friend Michael Olmsted in Springfield, Mo.:

    "Thank you for stirring memories of those times, those quiet spaces away from all the structures and events we call worshipful, when I was alone and conversing with God audibly as though we were walking together. Finding the kind of quiet without social distractions that hinder a ‘conversation’ with God are too rare in our society. But those unhindered moments are there for the claiming when we need them. I converse aloud and with no restrictions ... no secrets ... as a result of simple trust in God’s unfailing grace. This is how I discover God's gifts of peace, hope, and healing for my troubled soul."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for sharing these reflections, Michael. What you said about being "alone and conversing with God audibly" was what I often experienced as a farmboy when I could sing and pray aloud without being heard by anyone other than God--or later driving alone on car trips of an hour or hours. Since I wasn't a very good singer, I didn't sing very loud in church--but that was different when driving the tractor or on a car trip by myself. And praying in those same circumstances, aloud and uninhibited, was often very meaningful to me. That is why I refer to those places as being sacred spaces.

      Delete
  5. Thanks for this blog post, Leroy. I think that one can encounter/be encountered by God's presence/sacred spaces/places anywhere on earth, as well as in churches and synagogues, etc. Sacred places/spaces are encountered every day, since we are created in God's image, and the Holy Spirit dwells within us.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Garth, and you and I are in solid agreement on this matter. My concern, though, is that there are so many, including many church members, it seems, who make a much too great separation between the sacred and the "secular" and miss out on much for not being able to see "ordinary" places as also being potentially sacred.

      Delete
  6. Thinking Friend Glenn Hinson in Kentucky shares these comments:

    "I agree, Leroy. Our bodies (or persons) are God’s dwelling place, as Paul reminded the Corinthians. Our key to the sacred is to be attentive to God wherever we are and whatever we are doing. That was Brother Lawrence’s discovery."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comments, Dr. Hinson. Certainly one of the great challenges of the present age is to overcome all the demands for our attention (from 24/7 television, social media, a surrounding culture focused so much on sports and other entertainment, etc.) in order to be able to be attentive to God at all times and places.

      Delete
  7. Leroy,
    Thanks for continuing to write words that evoke! Thoughts evoked this time:
    Encounters with God happen anywhere. I am too likely to focus on my own encounters (sensings) which inclines me to overvalue “private” over “public” place/space [personal over communal].
    Contexts in which persons “can breathe” are sacred/prayer places. We fail when we allow/create contexts/places where a person exclaims “I can’t breathe!”
    “The praying of prayer / Is not in the words but the breath.” (James Dickey, “The Being”)
    Shalom, Dick

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comments, Dick. It was good to hear from you again. I am not sure it is possible to overvalue "private" spaces that are sacred because of meeting God there, but I think you are correct in pointing out that it is possible to undervalue "public" places/spaces that are sacred, and perhaps that is what I have tended to do.

      I don't remember knowing about James Dickey, who was the 18th U.S. Poet Laureate, but I didn't find the words you cited in his 1963 poem titled "The Being." But they reminded me of the 1818 hymn text by James Montgomery"

      Prayer is the soul’s sincere desire,
      Unuttered or expressed;
      The motion of a hidden fire
      That trembles in the breast.

      Prayer is the burden of a sigh,
      The falling of a tear,
      The upward glancing of an eye,
      When none but God is near.

      Prayer is the simplest form of speech
      That infant lips can try;
      Prayer, the sublimest strains that reach
      The Majesty on high.

      Prayer is the Christian’s vital breath,
      . . . .

      Delete
    2. Gee Leroy, the quoted words are in italics in section III in "Poems 1957-1967." Same at poetryfoundation.org: first Google hit for 'the being james dickey' in search. :-)

      Delete
    3. Thanks, Dick, for telling me (by email) that the words you referenced were on the next page in the PoetryFoundation link. I mistakenly thought what I saw on the first page was the complete poem and am embarrassed that I didn't have enough sense to turn the page.

      Delete
  8. Thinking Friend Virginia Belk in New Mexico shares the following comments, which are just part of a much longer email message:

    "Thank you, Leroy for these thoughts!

    "I felt God's presence very close and strong every time I drew near the 'window' rock for which the community was named and also at a Pueblo ruin called Quari in SE NM. I felt it every day last August when I arose and looked out at the ocean and sky, whether it was soggy and socked in or bright, glimmering gold on azure waves.

    "Our loving three faceted Creator Father-Teacher Savior-Mother Comforter Wisdom Way/God is everywhere; we have only to seek, look, be open to receive, recognize that One!"

    ReplyDelete
  9. And then a Thinking Friend in Maryland wrote,

    "I appreciate your post. As you know, I am really drawn to nature/wilderness, but am also moved by intentional spiritual spaces.

    "I was struck a few years ago by the notion that all space is either sacred or desecrated (de-sacred), which is a broader definition of sacred that I appreciate."

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am grateful for these comments, and especially for the differentiation, which I don't remember hearing before, between "all space being either sacred or desecrated."

      Delete
  10. This morning I received the following comments from Thinking Friend Andrew Bolton in England:

    "Lovely piece! Thank you!

    "There is an ambiguity between Jesus and the Temple. The Jerusalem Temple was sacred space in Jewish culture and figures prominently in the gospels. Jesus is found in the temple as a 12 year old talking with religious leaders. Jesus’ defence at his arrest was that he taught openly at the temple. Jesus was also a prophetic critic of the temple when he turned over the tables of the money changers etc. and said how dare sacred space be corrupted so all nations no longer had room to pray, and that the outrageous prices for sacrificial animals was daylight robbery. For his protest, both Mark and Luke say that the religious leaders wanted to kill him, but the crowd protected him. Protesting injustice in sacred space led to crucifixion.

    "I think Jesus’ freely forgiving sin as he encountered people in Galilee and elsewhere was also a criticism of the temple. Forgiveness, atonement, did not depend on sacrifice in the temple, God can forgive you freely anywhere. Of course, this was criticized because it was undercutting the temple system and was bad for temple business.

    "Sacred space abused needs to be reclaimed. This is particularly true of our earth and climate change."

    ReplyDelete
  11. A few minutes ago I received the following comments from a Thinking Friend, and I appreciate her sharing these words with me--and you readers of this blog.

    "I agree with what you've written. Because of some unfortunate incidents with the church in my past, I learned a lesson a long time ago: Don't look for God through the eyes of the church. Instead, look at the church through the eyes of God. That is the only philosophy that has enabled me to continue to attend services."

    ReplyDelete