Last month, a Facebook friend posted the poem “The Touch of the Master’s Hand,” a poem I remember reading and using in sermons, in the 1950s. Now, sixty-five years later, I have mixed emotions about that once-popular poem penned a hundred years ago.
Rather than take the space to paste the poem here, I am giving you this link to read it online. Or you can listen to it impressively recited on YouTube—and here is the link (with subtitles) to it being sung in 2017.
The Poet
Myra Brooks Welch was best known for the poem introduced
above. Myra (1877~1959) was born in Illinois, but in 1920 she and her family
moved to La Verne, Calif. They were members of the Church of the Brethren, the
Anabaptist denomination that was prominent in that city.
Ms. Welch reported that she heard a speaker address a group
of students on the power of God to bring out the best in people. She said that
she was inspired by what she heard and wrote “The Touch of the Master’s Hand” in
just 30 minutes!
Her poem was published in the February 26, 1921, issue of The
Gospel Messenger, the Church of the Brethren’s official church paper (now
known as just Messenger).
The Poem
Myra Welch’s poem spread across the country, and I heard it and was favorably impressed by it, while still a teen-aged Southern Baptist in
Missouri—and as some of you know, I started preaching in 1954 at age 16.
Wikipedia (here)
gives a good, succinct summary: “The poem tells of a battered old violin that
is about to be sold as the last item at an auction for a pittance, until a
violinist steps out of the audience and plays the instrument, demonstrating its
beauty and true value.”
Then comes the primary point: “The violin then sells for
$3,000 instead of a mere $3. The poem ends by comparing this instrument touched
by the hand of a master musician to the life of a sinner that is touched by the
hand of God.” (Myra, though, no doubt considered Jesus Christ to be the
Master.)
The Problem
While I have no doubt that there are many people whose lives
have been significantly changed by having been touched by “the Master’s hand," sadly, there seems to be far too little evidence of such change in far too many
people who claim to be followers of Jesus.
Those who are evangelicals, as I was in the 1950s, are the
Christians most likely to resonate with the message of Ms. Welch’s poem. But now
it seems that some conservative evangelicals are prominently pushing policies
that seem opposed to the teachings of Jesus.
There are unfortunate moral lapses evident in the lives of some
Christians in all denominations, as well as people of other religions and of no
religion. But I am writing here not about personal piety but about problematic positions
on public policy, of which there are many.
The problem is not just one in this country, however. Think
of the situation in Ethiopia, for example. Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed is said to
be (here) “a devout
Evangelical Pentecostal Christian of the Full Gospel Believer’s Church.”
The Ethiopian PM reportedly attends church regularly and “occasionally
ministers in preaching and teaching.” Further, “he frequently underscores the
importance of faith.” By his public religiosity, he seems to be an example of a
man who has been “touched by the Master’s hand.”
To the great chagrin of many, though, in the past year the policies
of Abiy Ahmed have led to what is being called “war crimes.” While garnering
little news coverage in this country, the civil war in Ethiopia has been marked
by military atrocities as well as by a huge humanitarian crisis.
The Oct. 9 issue of The Economist reports that “Ethiopia
is deliberately starving its own citizens.” Some 400,000 people in the northern
part of the country are facing “ catastrophic hunger.”
How could such problems possibly result from the policies of
a man who has been “touched by the Master’s hand?”
_____
** For a
broader description of the current civil war in Ethiopia, see
this article by Philip Jenkins in the Oct. 8 issue of The Christian
Century.
Local Thinking Friend Bruce Morgan just now sent the following comments that in a few words express well some of what I would like to have said in the blog article:
ReplyDelete"Leroy, I know the poem and love the poem - and I think it is a pietistic metaphor for the possibilities that exist when Christ is able to bring about a total transformation in a person's life. I, agree with you, however, that for far too many people this transformation only occurs at some spiritual level, without full application at the societal level that reveals a total change of heart. Think of all the slave owning Christians - devout believers who never saw the contradiction between faith and social ethics. Think of all the anti-vax Christians who put their self-interest over their responsibility to society. The poem is a lovely poem - but the full implications are lost on a host of Christian believers."
Either I didn't know or I've forgotten that you started preaching at 16. I didn't start till I was 18! Someday I'll tell you what you missed out on in those two years. LOL!!
ReplyDeleteI suppose there are a lot of old hymns/poems that touched our hearts as evangelicals and even as liberals. We still sing many of them even in my most progressive UCC church, although we've altered the lyrics to make them inclusive.
The recent NYTimes article about some very personally decent men in everyday life getting caught up in the angry frenzy of the crowds in Washington on January 6 is most telling. You might remember the research done by social scientists in the 1950s regarding authoritarianism because of the shock of an "enlightened" Germany turning fascist and committing horrific crimes against humanity. Then there were the USA's southern white Christians watching lynchings with glee and later screaming at black children trying to attend school. Probably we have to stop looking at humanity through a religious lens and, instead, study it through a scientific lens to get better understanding of what and who we are. I suspect that in the end -- if there is a progressive end for humanity -- we will find the moral compass somewhere other than in religion/spirituality.
Hey, Anton, I didn’t realize you were such a late bloomer! I became pastor of a small mission church about 2½ months after my 17th birthday and was ordained while still 18, about three months before my 19th birthday.
DeleteRegarding the main point of your last paragraph: Yes, there are far, far too many examples of the failings of “Christians” through the centuries, including, of course, the German Christians of the 1930s and ’40s and the southern U.S. Christians in the 1950s and ’60s. But there were also Christians such as D. Bonhoeffer in Germany, a man who did seem to have been touched by the Master’s hand. And there were a number of White Christians as well as MLK, Jr. and many other Black Christians who were touched by the Master’s hand and worked diligently for the liberation of Blacks in the South (and elsewhere). I certainly don’t know that there is any indication that there were better, more effective advocates of freedom and justice by non-religious people during those fateful years in Germany of the U.S. South.
Here are thought-provoking comments received in an email about 7:15 from Thinking Friend Eric Dollard in Chicago:
ReplyDelete"Thanks, Leroy, for mentioning 'The Touch of the Master's Hand. I had not heard of the poem previously.
"The war in Tigray province in Ethiopia is clearly horrific and an international peacekeeping force may be needed to prevent a catastrophe. The sad irony is that the PM, Abi Ahmed, claims to be a Christian and has received a Nobel peace prize for working out a settlement between Ethiopia and Eritrea.
"The war in Tigray appears to be motivated by tribalism and ethnic rivalry. Ethiopia is an ethnically complex country and its future cohesion is questionable. It is not Switzerland; it is more like Yugoslavia.
"But as bad as the situation in Tigray may be, was the U S any better in Afghanistan? About 2,500 Americans were killed there, but 164,000 Afghans died, mostly from U S military actions. We spent over a trillion dollars on the war in Afghanistan, but very little of it trickled down to the people or to the villages. Most of the money went to U S contractors and the Afghan ruling class.
"Our government, despite its checkered record, needs to pressure the Ethiopian government to find a peaceful solution in Tigray while allowing humanitarian aid."
Thanks for your comments, Eric. And thanks for mentioning that Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize (in 2019). I have read that there has been considerable effort encouraging the Peace Prize committee to revoke that award. And, yes, it seems that you are correct in pointing out that to a large extent the civil war in Ethiopia is based upon tribal and ethnic rivalry.
DeleteI have long been critical of the U.S. war in Afghanistan and supported Pres. Biden’s withdrawal of U.S. troops there, as ugly as it was. Since then, there has been reports, as you probably know, of widespread hunger and the possibility of massive starvation in that country—but that is due not to what the U.S. had done but because of the Taliban taking over the country and not having the wherewithal to take care of the people in the country.
And then this succinct comment from Thinking Friend Glenn Hinson in Kentucky:
ReplyDelete"A very good point, Leroy. As Merton has said, 'If you don’t live it, you don’t believe it.'”
Thanks for again reading and responding to my blog post, Dr. Hinson. Merton's words certainly are appropriate for the point I was trying to make.
DeleteFundamentalism has been salvation to many people. It provides an iron rule that can save a drowning soul. Unfortunately, it can become a heavy yoke for others, and its iron rules can become a source of cynicism and rebellion. Christianity has no clear growth mechanism to uplift those growing in faith who need a new metaphor. It is usually a lonely pilgrimage in the wilderness to find a path to mature faith. Many others never find their way and either drop out or become lost souls inhabiting a dead faith, which frequently leads to disastrous results.
ReplyDelete-Craig Dempsey
My mother used to recite by memory that poem, "The Touch of the Master's Hand." She knew many poems by memory and during her final years we used to encourage her to recite those poems which she had learned during her younger years as a student and teacher. We bought a book of classic poems so we could follow along as she recited them and so we could occasionally prompt her memory when needed.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing this, Clif. I was impressed that your mother could recite this poem by memory. June's mother, who died at age 93, was much like your mother in that way: late in her life she too could quote many poems that she had memorized early in life.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHere are comments received early this morning from Thinking Friend Kevin Heifner in Arkansas:
ReplyDelete"I enjoy reading your weekly blog and also the comments of your thinking friends. The comments above for whatever reason resonate more than most weeks. Superb all. My only contribution is a personal vignette.
"On October 20 I wrote a post entitled 'how to lose an argument.' My suggestion was if you want to lose an argument really badly, try to argue someone out of a position rooted in their personal experience. And then I blathered on. The quote shared above by Thomas Merton was unknown to me, appreciated, and superiorly stated. A side benefit personally of an excellent thread. Thanks to all."
Thank you, Kevin, for your kind words about those who commented above.
DeleteOn Oct. 20 I read what you posted on Facebook about "how to lose an argument," and I am pasting that below for those who do not see your Facebook posts:
"How to Lose an Argument…
"If you ever want to lose an argument really badly, here’s my advice… Try to argue someone out of a position based on their personal experience.
"No data, statistic, clever rhetoric, or algorithm is sufficient. All are antiquated weapons when deployed against experiences lived and lessons learned in the ditches and mountain tops of life. Such arguments will always fail against someone who believes…
"The power of prayer to one who has seen it change their life or those of loved ones.
The world is not nihilistic nor random. It is based on some higher form of order. Whether they call it the creative force, the great mystery, or God… Once experienced, any man-made argument pales.
"That love, not suffering, is the ultimate reality… To a mother who cradles her newborn.
That goodness, kindness, and self-sacrifice are superior to selfishness and narcissism… To one who gives so that others may have.
"That the fight for justice or right orderliness of all things for all people… for one in the fight…Will one day be the rule, not the exception.
"The reason you will never convince such people with words alone is because they have lived… But you have only pondered."
Thank you for sharing this information with us. I first read this poem by my personal evangelism book where I first found the post and then studied it and I later found your blog on that poem by Myra Brooks Welch. The poem has been a blessing to learn the testimony of a changed life but also can be taken advantage as I read. Just like using the "sinner's prayer". Some people would be encouraged to pray this prayer and then they will be Christians but the next day through the prayer like a free ticket to Heaven. However, those who made the prayer live back as unbelievers. It can be misunderstood and misused if one does not know how to share it or interpret it as if there is no transformational change, there is no conversion as well.
ReplyDelete