Saturday, February 8, 2025

Remembering John Cobb and His Transdisciplinary Theology

 Several months ago, I intended to post a blog article today titled “Happy 100th Birthday, Dr. Cobb!” He was alive and well at that time, but sadly, he passed away about six weeks ago. Still, I am remembering him today/tomorrow and I hope you will enjoy learning a little more about him and his theological thinking. 

John Boswell Cobb Jr. was born on February 9, 1925, and passed away on the day after Christmas. He was a “missionary kid” (MK), born in Kobe, Japan, to parents who were Methodist missionaries.

Until age 15, John lived primarily in Kobe and received most of his early education in the multi-ethnic Canadian Academy in that central Japan city. (Several of the Baptist MKs I knew in Japan, including the two children of Dickson Yagi [introduced below] went to high school at Canadian Academy.)

Dr. Cobb taught theology at the Claremont School of Theology (in California) from 1958 until his retirement in 1990. In 2014 he became the first theologian elected to the prestigious American Academy of Arts and Sciences for his interdisciplinary work in ecology, economics, and biology.

At least 25 years ago, Dr. Cobb moved to Pilgrim Place, a retirement home in Claremont. Thinking Friend Dickson Yagi was a faculty colleague of mine at Seinan Gakuin University in Japan. Not long after Dickson returned to the U.S., Dr. Cobb invited him to retire at Pilgrim Place, which he did in 2002.

Last August, I wrote to Dickson regarding Dr. Cobb. Dickson responded, “John Cobb’s brain is as sharp as ever. ... He lives in the partial nursing quarters now, so I don’t see him very often. But he still speaks in public .... He is a very courteous and pleasant, intelligent man.”*1

John Cobb has been influential in a wide range of disciplines, including biology, ecology, economics, social ethics, and theology. I find his thought and writing quite valuable because of how he sees these disciplines as being interrelated and overlapping.

As Wikipedia correctly states, “Although Cobb is most often described as a theologian, the overarching tendency of his thought has been toward the integration of many different areas of knowledge.” Indeed, this sort of integration is what theology ought to be but so often hasn’t been.

Ecological themes have been pervasive in Cobb's work since 1969 (!), when he turned his attention to the ecological crisis. He became convinced that environmental issues constituted humanity’s most pressing problem. His book Is It Too Late? A Theology of Ecology was published in 1971.

In 1973, Cobb and his colleague David Ray Griffin (1939~2022) co-founded the Center for Process Studies (CPS) at Claremont.*2 Three years later, they published Process Theology: An Introductory Exposition, a book of singular importance.

In the Foreword, the authors reject much of the traditional theistic understanding of God, according to which “God seems to be the archetype of the dominant, inflexible, emotional, completely independent (read “strong”) male. Process theology denies the existence of this God” (p. 10).*3

Cobb published Becoming a Thinking Christian in 1993. The first paragraph of the Preface states that the book is for people who are lay Christians “in one of the oldline Protestant churches.”

Cobb perceived that many intelligent people in the churches “are still operating out of a simplistic view of faith. Too many have been led to assume that faith is incompatible with intellectual challenge and integrity. … that is the problem to which this book is addressed.”

I fully agree with Cobb’s expressed purpose for that book. In fact, it was just the following year that I started writing a somewhat similar book provisionally titled “Christian Faith and Intellectual Honesty.”

Because of soon being elected to heavy administration responsibilities at the educational institution where I had taught university and seminary classes since 1968, I was, sadly, unable to make much progress on that writing project.

My strong desire, as well as Cobb’s, is for all Christians to be thinking Christians—as well as for all those who are no longer, or never were, Christians to be thinking people. Most of my blog readers are, thankfully, such people, and many of them are on my Thinking Friends mailing list.

I hope some of you will now go to a library or to Amazon.com (or elsewhere) and obtain a copy of Cobb’s book. (There are several “very good” used copies available at Amazon for less than $7.00, including postage.)

_____

*1 I heard Dr. Cobb speak in Japan (in 1995) as well as in the U.S., and I visited with him personally on both occasions. In the 1980s when I taught at Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary, Dr. Cobb attended an academic meeting there.  At the close of the meeting, I had the privilege of driving him to the Kansas City International Airport and much enjoyed the conversation we had on that occasion. I fully agree with Dickson’s closing words about him.

*2 In 1974, Marjorie Hewitt Suchocki (b. 1933) received her Ph.D. degree at Claremont Graduate School. A few years later, she authored God Christ Church: A Practical Guide to Process Theology (1982, 1989). After teaching in various universities, she was a faculty member at Claremont School of Divinity from 1990 until her retirement in 2002. During that time, she was also a co-director of CPS. At an academic meeting in 2006, I had the opportunity to hear her speak and to have a private conversation with her.

*3 The paragraph on the previous page where they reject the idea of God as a “controlling power” is very similar to the fundamental idea of Thomas Jay Oord, whom I introduced in my January 10 blog post.

Note: Dr. Cobb’s last book was published in 2023, shortly after his 98th birthday, and much of that book was written in 2022. It is titled simply Confessions and is a very personal—and timely—book. I bought the $10 Kindle version last year and carefully read the 200+ pages. I highly recommend it. 

7 comments:

  1. Dr. Seat: among my many book-mentors, Dr. Glenn Hinson is one whose standards and breadth of understanding in Baptist history were especially encouraging. I am grateful for friends who benefited from his direct supervision and model at Southern Seminary. It was as a student there that I frequently heard about Professor John Cobb and Process Theology--no wonder, as part of the professor's tasks there apparently was to shake up our thinking. I am grateful that they shaped mine. In my college teaching of history and allied research, I had little occasion to hear about or follow up on Cobb's thinking, though, if I had been more astute, I might have drawn comparisons between his work and my focus on postmodern trends in my dissertation. I think comparisons between Cobb and the "Speech Thinkers" is a good project. I find associations and suggestions in that.

    I am moreover grateful that in our church there is a book study group, decades-old, that examines boundary perspectives in our quest to understand God Jesus Church in refreshing ways that just may be applicable to the "process" studies of theology. Challenging but fruitful, not for everyone, but that we find expanded and strengthened ways to "faith" our way in society is encouraging. Led by Steve Rutherford, we are finishing up another book by J. Philip Newell on Celtic Christianity. In two weeks guest teachers Buddy and Kay Shurden will facilitate a series from Daniel O. Snyder's Praying in the Dark.
    These studies are transformative of soul and mind, challenging us to Jesus's own model of believing.

    Thank you for your stimulating words today.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Dr. Summers, for reading and responding so early this morning.

      (For any of you who see this but are not on my Thinking Friends mailing list, in the email I sent my TFs this mor​ning regarding this new blog post, I mentioned that Dr. Glenn Hinson, an influential seminary professor, author, and spiritual leader--as well as, I am happy to say, a good personal friend who regularly read and commented on my blog posts--passed away on January 30 at the age of 93.)

      I am somewhat envious of the book study group in your church. I don't remember hearing of Daniel O. Snyder previously, but I am happy to know about his book and glad your group is going to be studying it--and that you will have such good leaders of it. I don't know Kay, but I have known Buddy Shurden for decades and have chatted with him on a couple of occasions. And when I looked up Snyder's book and found that it was recommended by Mahan Siler, whom I know, and Parker Palmer, a couple of whose books I have read, I decided to buy (on Kindle for only $3) a copy to read.

      Delete
  2. Thank you Leroy. Very interesting to hear background about a famous theologian who has also influenced my thinking.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Andrew. I am always glad to hear from you, and I am not surprised that you have read and been influenced by John Cobb. Having just read a bit of the Introduction in the book mentioned above, my guess is you would be interested in it also. Part II is about peacemaking. Snyder seems to have an transdisciplinary approach to theology that is somewhat similar to Dr. Cobb's.

      Delete
  3. I traveled a long meandering path to theology, only later realizing a lot of what I was reading was in an attempt to address theological questions. So I missed some milestones, and I thank you for introducing me to John Cobb. I like the title "Transdisciplinary Theology." In our world of academic silos I see a great need for broad liberal arts learning. Indeed, way back when I was in college, philosophers were worrying about what was left for philosophy to do. So some did weird language analysis, or strange psychology. The answer was right there all along, everyone wants to get a "Doctor of Philosophy." Well, I do not have a Ph.D. in anything, but I have made a lot of mileage out of my BS in philosophy and religion. Thank you, Iowa State! Like Socrates, there is a lot I do not know.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your comments, Craig. Indeed, for someone who has a Bachelor of Science degree, you have engaged in broad liberal arts (and philosophical/theological) learning through the years.

      What you wrote reminded me to introduce again #2 in my book "Thirty True Things Everyone Needs to Know Now" and the related blog post I made on in January 2018).
      https://theviewfromthisseat.blogspot.com/2018/01/ttt-2-better-we-know-god-broader-and.html

      "There was a time, long ago, when theology was widely considered to be the 'queen of the sciences.' It was so called because if God is the creator and sustainer of the entire universe from the beginning to the present and on into the vast future, there is nothing that is not related to God.

      "So theology, the study of God, must include everything since everything is related to God."

      Delete
  4. Yesterday, I received an email from Thinking Friend Greg Hadley in Japan. Among other things he wrote,

    "What marvelous people you have known and interacted with. Dr. Hinson cut an impressive figure, and from the website I could easily discern that he was both respected and much loved. Also, that John Cobb was writing up until he was 99 – that is impressive indeed. What a polymath! We need more people like him. Now more than ever, since he has returned to the Logos who spoke him into existence."

    ReplyDelete